The number you gave your CEO includes gifts that won't close


The Next-Year Test

​​
​​

"Maybe next year" is not a real pipeline strategy.

If you look at most major gift pipelines in November, you'll see a group of gifts quietly pushed to next year, each with a tactful note attached.

"Interested, but the timing isn't right."

"Asked us to come back next year."

"Not ready to decide."

Every note sounds reasonable. Most pipelines count them all the same way, which is how a forecast ends up looking healthier than it is.

We have plenty of qualified prospects. Gifts stall at conversion, and one place it breaks is a donor without a sharp enough reason to give now. "Maybe next year" is what that sounds like out loud.

There's a simple fix: ask one question before the conversation ends. Call it the Next-Year Test. It helps sort every "maybe next year" into active, deferred, or cultivation.

Two donors, same words

When a donor says "not now, maybe next year," we usually respect their timing and schedule a follow-up. Most of the time, that's the right move.

Problems start when we assume the donor agreed to something they actually didn't.

Some donors have a real reason to wait, like a business sale closing in the spring, a pledge ending in June, or a family decision about a trust. They can tell you what's changing and when, and they'll often suggest when to reconnect. Their interest is real; the timing is just the issue.

Other donors like us, enjoy the relationship, and have no reason next year will look any different. Ask what might change, and the answer goes vague. They don't offer a next step.

Both groups say the same thing at first. What they say next is what sets them apart.

The question

"What do you expect will be different next year?"

This is a gentle question that gives the donor space to explain the delay.

If they mention a specific event or decision, we have something to plan for. If not, it's probably a polite no. Either way, it's more honest than just setting a follow-up date.

Run the math

For a gift officer, "maybe next year" feels like a relationship to protect. For a chief, it's the number already reported to the CEO.

Say you're carrying 10 major gift opportunities at $100,000 each. 5 have engaged decision makers and an obvious next step. The other 5 got pushed to next year with no specific commitment.

On paper, that's a $1 million pipeline, but half of it has no clear path to a decision.

A healthy revenue dashboard can hide a fragile pipeline. You may see the pipeline as full and slow down new prospect work. And the gap stays hidden until the expected gifts don't close, usually in the last quarter, when there's no time left to fill it.

If timing is the issue, we should change how we count the gift. The relationship itself doesn't have to change.

The Next-Year Test: 3 buckets

1. Active. Interest expressed, a defined next step, and a real basis for a decision this year. Counts in this year's forecast.

2. Deferred. The donor named a specific reason to wait, and we know when or how to come back. Counts in the year of the real decision date. Never as committed revenue. (Thoughtful strategic patience beats urgent mediocrity, and this is the bucket where patience pays.)

3. Cultivation. The donor cares about the work, but there's no sign a gift decision is coming. This stays in a relationship plan and out of the forecast.

All three groups deserve real stewardship, but only the first two have a reason for a future ask.

One of my goals this year is simple to say but hard to do: every prospect in our pipeline should have a clear path. Sorting like this helps turn a "maybe next year" into a defined plan.

If you sort that 10-gift pipeline, this year's number drops from $1 million to $500,000. That hurts, but I'd rather have a smaller, honest pipeline than a bigger one based on hope.

I've made a free sort sheet for the Next-Year Test. It's one page with the question, the moved-date check, the sort, and a line for your CEO. Reply with NEXT YEAR and I'll send it to you.

Your Turn

The moved-date check. Open your pipeline report and filter for every opportunity where the close date has moved at least once. Write down what percent of your pipeline dollars that is. Then pick the 5 oldest.

For each one, answer 2 questions:

1. Did the donor name something specific that will change?
2. Do we have an agreed next step or date?

Yes to both? It’s Deferred. Keep it, and move the close date to the real decision date.

Anything less is Cultivation. Take it out of this year’s forecast.

On My Radar

​Superforecasting by Philip Tetlock and Dan Gardner is about one habit that makes predictions honest: assigning a probability instead of a yes or no. It's the right read for November, when many of us are defending a year-end number and drafting next year's goal. I ask gift officers to put a percent chance on every gift. If a gift has 30% next to it, nobody mistakes it for committed revenue.

Pick the Q1 topic

Starting in January, I'm building each quarter of CFW around one problem you pick. Tap one answer below. I'll share what wins in December. Don't see a problem you want addressed? Send it to me. I respond to every message.

Coming Next Week

Three readers sent me the same concern over the last few weeks, and burnout among nonprofit CEOs jumped 17 points this year. Next Sunday, I'll share the Load-Bearing Check: three questions to help you find the weight no one ever assigned you.

Until next Sunday,
Christine

P.S. This issue closes Donor Objections at Chief Fundraiser Attitude. Missed the first 2? "We already give elsewhere" and "We need to see the numbers first" are both on the site.


This newsletter grows one fundraiser at a time, and mostly by word of mouth. If it's useful, forward it to one Chief Fundraiser who'd get something out of it.

Did a fundraiser send this to you? Chief Fundraiser Weekly is free every Sunday.

I’m Christine Bork, Chief Development Officer at the American Academy of Pediatrics.

I write CFW to share what I’m learning as I lead a growing team and try to do the work in a way that’s sustainable and thoughtful.


© 2026 Christine Bork / Chief Fundraiser Weekly. All rights reserved.